The US Department of Homeland Security has published a new proposed rule that would make people ineligible for US citizenship if their credit-scores were poor.
Notionally, the rule-change is meant to prevent immigrants from becoming
burdens on the welfare system (migrants do not make disproportionate
use of any public welfare system).
However, the credit reporting bureaus are notoriously inaccurate and
arbitrary in the credit-scores they assign; if you have a lot of assets
but do not borrow money, you will have a much lower credit-rating than
if you unwisely enroll in a number of high cost/high fee store cards and
pay them off after running up debts on them and paying significant
interest (I am allergic to debt, and with the exception of my mortgage
have no debts at all; because of this I have a fairly low credit-score,
despite the fact that both my wife and I earn very good livings).
What’s more, the credit-reporting sector is riddled with security holes; notoriously, Equifax doxxed the entire adult population of America
by breaching more than 150 million residents’ financial data.
Integrating credit scores into the immigration process will grant the
bureaux a permanent government contract and funnel tax-dollars to them
forever, despite their routine errors, racial bias, and spurious
guilt-by-statistical-association.
Finally, the DHS’s change is an appeal to selfishness and cruelty: if
America is unwilling to accept migrants who are indigent or who need
assistance, what does it say about us as a nation?
It’s a Made-in-America version of China’s notorious Citizen Scores.
